Is It Better to Paint or Stain or use a Deck-Over Coating on a Deck?

When it comes to maintaining your deck, one of the most common questions homeowners face is whether to paint or stain or deck-over coat it. These options have their pros and cons, and the best choice depends on your specific needs and preferences. Let’s explore the differences to help you make an informed decision.

1. Aesthetic Appeal

• Staining: Enhances the natural beauty of the wood, highlighting its grain and texture. Stains come in various opacities, from transparent to semi-transparent to solid.
• Painting: Offers a wide range of colors and finishes, allowing for a more customized look. It can create a solid, uniform appearance.
• Deck-Over Coating: Offers a wide range of colors. Very durable and will fill minor imperfections to create a solid, uniform appearance.

2. Durability and Maintenance

• Stain: While it may not last as long as paint, stains penetrate the wood, providing a natural look. They typically require reapplication every few years, depending on exposure to the elements.
• Painting: Generally more durable and good UV and moisture resistance. However, it can chip and peel over time, requiring more frequent maintenance.
• Deck-Over Coating: The most durable option and excellent UV and moisture resistance. Does not chip and peel as quickly as paint and requires less frequent maintenance.

3. Application Process

• Staining: Easier to apply, often requiring just one or two coats. It’s important to choose the right type of stain for your wood and climate.
• Painting: Requires a clean, dry surface and often a primer for best results. The application can be more labor-intensive, especially if multiple coats are needed.
• Deck-Over Coating: Requires a clean and dry surface. Primer is typically not needed. Application is relatively easy and usually only two coats are needed.

4. Environmental Considerations

• Stain: Generally considered more eco-friendly, especially if you opt for water-based stains. They tend to have lower VOC levels.
• Paint: Some paints contain VOCs (volatile organic compounds), which can be harmful to the environment. Look for low-VOC options if you choose to paint.
• Deck-Over Coating: Some deck-over coatings contain VOCs (volatile organic compounds), which can be harmful to the environment. Look for low-VOC options if you choose a deck-over coating.

5. Cost

• Staining: Typically less expensive upfront, but consider the frequency of reapplication when budgeting for long-term maintenance.
• Painting: Initial costs can be higher due to the need for primer and multiple coats. However, the longevity of paint can offset these costs over time.
• Deck-Over Coating: Initial costs can be high due to the cost of the deck-over product. The excellent durability of the deck-over coating will greatly offset the cost over time.

Ultimately, the choice between painting and staining your deck comes down to your personal preferences, budget, and maintenance willingness. If you prioritize durability and a wide color selection, painting may be the way to go. If you prefer the ultimate product, use a good quality deck-over product for increased durability and lifespan. If you prefer a natural look and easier application, staining could be your best bet.

Nationwide has your every option for Deck refinishing:

• Staining: WOOD-TECH™ eco-friendly water-based stains are 100% Acrylic and are available in Clear Gloss, Transparent, Semi-Transparent and Full Body Wood Colors.
• Painting: WEATHER-GUARD™ 100% Acrylic Latex Enamel Trim & Deck Paint is available in a beautiful semi-gloss finish and has excellent durability.
• Deck-Over Coating: DECK GUARDIAN™ Acrylic Deck-Over Coating is an elastomeric high build coating that will fill imperfections and has extreme durability.

Final Thoughts

Before making your decision, consider consulting with a professional to assess your deck’s condition and get tailored advice. Whether you choose to paint or stain, proper preparation and maintenance will ensure your deck remains beautiful for years to come.

Contact a Nationwide Protective Coating Mfrs., Inc. Coating Expert to discuss the options and choose the perfect coating choice for your deck.